Is a pay as you go call answering service cheaper than a monthly plan?

A pay as you go call answering service is cheaper than a monthly plan only when you send it very few calls, because the per-call or per-minute rate is usually higher than a bundle's; once your missed calls are steady every month, a monthly bundle with no contract normally costs less for the same calls and is just as easy to cancel.

A Pickuply receptionist answering a garage's customer: it gives the Saturday opening hours, takes the car's registration and the caller's number, and pencils in a 10am MOT for the team to confirm
A real Pickuply receptionist taking a booking for Northside Motors, our made-up sample garage. Call or type to it yourself →

Free tool: put your own call numbers into the missed call cost calculator to see the bookings and revenue lost each week, month and year.

How pay as you go answering is charged

With pay as you go there's no monthly allowance. You pay for each call answered, or for each minute of talk time, often from a balance you top up in advance. Some services add a small monthly line fee or number rental even on pay as you go, so check whether "no monthly fee" really means nothing is charged in a quiet month.

It appeals to businesses whose calls come in bursts: a seasonal trade, a one-person business that only misses calls on busy weeks, or someone trying an answering service for the first time without committing to a plan.

The break-even sum

You can work out which is cheaper with three numbers from your own call log: how many calls you miss in a normal month, how long they last, and the prices you've been quoted. Here's a worked example with made-up figures; replace them with yours.

Say you miss 40 calls a month and each lasts about three minutes, so 120 minutes. If a pay as you go service charges £1 a call, that's £40 a month. A monthly bundle of 150 minutes for £39 covers the same calls with room to spare. If you only missed 10 calls a month, pay as you go would cost £10 against the same £39 bundle, and pay as you go wins.

The point where they cross depends entirely on your numbers, so do the sum both ways for a quiet month and a busy one. The missed call cost calculator helps with the first half: how many calls you're missing and what they're worth.

Small print to check

  • Is there a minimum charge per call, so a 20-second wrong number costs the same as a five-minute enquiry?
  • Are calls rounded up to the next minute?
  • Does the balance expire if you don't use it?
  • Is there still a monthly line, number or account fee?
  • Do evenings, weekends and bank holidays cost more per call?
  • Are bookings, emailed messages or calendar connections extra?

Pay as you go versus a monthly plan with no contract

The main reason people want pay as you go is to avoid being locked in. A monthly plan with no minimum term gives most of that freedom: you can stop at the end of any month. What you lose is paying nothing in a month with no calls, which matters only if your calls really do stop for weeks at a time.

If your missed calls are steady, a bundle is usually cheaper and easier to budget. If they're rare or very seasonal, pay as you go can be, as long as the small print above doesn't eat the saving.

Step by step

  1. Count a normal month. Note how many calls you missed and roughly how long each lasted.
  2. Price pay as you go. Multiply by the per-call or per-minute rate, then add any monthly fees.
  3. Price a monthly bundle. Pick the bundle that covers your minutes and add the overage for a busy month.
  4. Compare busy and quiet months. Do both sums for your quietest and busiest months, not just an average.
  5. Test before you commit. Call the service as a customer, and check the contract terms before giving card details.

Where Pickuply fits

Pickuply isn't pay as you go. It's a monthly bundle with no contract, so you can cancel at the end of any month. Starter is £39 a month for 150 call minutes, then £0.30 a minute over; Pro is £89 for 400 minutes. Only calls forwarded to it use minutes, so if you divert just the calls you miss, you pay for those. There's a 14-day free trial, and you can call your receptionist in the browser before signing up, with no card.

Free to try on a call in your browser. No card needed. Or start without a website, or hear a sample call first.

Questions

Is pay as you go cheaper for a sole trader?

Only if you miss very few calls. Count a normal month: if it's a handful, pay as you go can win; if it's a few every day, a monthly bundle is usually cheaper.

Does Pickuply offer pay as you go?

No. It's a monthly plan with no contract. Starter is £39 for 150 minutes, then £0.30 a minute.

Can I pause a monthly plan in a quiet season?

With a no-contract plan you can cancel at the end of a month and sign up again later. Check whether your settings and number are kept.

Do I pay for calls I answer myself?

Not if you divert only unanswered calls. Only calls that reach the service count.

What about calls that hang up straight away?

Ask each service. Some charge a minimum per call, which makes pay as you go dearer if you get a lot of short calls.